ChurchillGot a 5 pack on promo. Of the 5 in this pack 3 were just okay in all categories and 2 were great. I would not expect R&J to have this much variation in overall quality. Like others have mentioned it seems 5 packs can be hit and miss.351
October 9, 2018
GLENN C.
ChurchillAn incredible tasting smoke that offers so much! Perfect construction coupled with a perfect draw leaves you perfectly satisfied.551
September 22, 2018
Bob B.
ChurchillSo far I've smoked 5 cigars from the box and everyone has needed a correction for an uneven burn 4 or 5 times. I will never buy again.451
August 22, 2017
DAVID L.
ChurchillThe draw and construction are great and the burn is ok but flavor is actually surprisingly good. I think I prefer the flavor on this blend than the Reserva Royale one. Great value for money. Always a mild cigar but one that can be savored any time in the day.451
July 21, 2017
Paulo R.
ChurchillA delightful daily smoke for me. This is my go to cigar. The packaging is ideal for on the go. I keep these is a separate humidor to prevent them from being hijacked. Starts delightful and builds to an almost perfect smoke for me. A punch is the way to go. Holds up well to a nice wet firm bite. I get a lot of compliments about the wonderful aromas.451
May 17, 2017
RICHARD J.
ChurchillGreat smokes. Slow burning with smooth taste. I enjoy them afterwork while I relax and reflect. Will buy again.551
May 4, 2017
JACK R.
ChurchillInconsistent burn and have to relight several times. Would be a ok cigar if not for that. Just very disappointed for the price.251
April 11, 2017
Teddy F.
ChurchillMy palate is still developing so take this revire eoth a grain of salt.
This stick started out a bit more harsh the I expected the flavors were great just not white as smooth as I had hoped trough the first third.
The second third was much more mellow but I had a hard time keeping it lit although I didn't give it much rest time after removing it from my 69% humidity storage. The flavors were great with a bit of leather and vanilla.
The final third really exploded in flavor getting stronger and more defined in the vanilla and earthiness. The draw tightened up here though making me work a bit harder for it.
All in all a solid stick that worked well with my smooth afternoon.451
April 2, 2017
Daniel F.
ChurchillThis is a medium bodied cigar with flavor notes of cedar earth nuts and a sweetness upon each draw. This pairs excellent with dark roast Colombian coffee.451
March 20, 2017
Andrew H.
ChurchillLoved this cigar hands down great smoke. This cigar is in my favorite brands the Churchill is a great hour long smoke551
February 27, 2017
Sean G.
ChurchillI suffered through two thirds of this hoping that I'd find some redeeming quality. I did not. The burn was out of control and required several relights. Trash. Also it tasted completely flat and one dimensional. Trash. And the one taste it did have was that if a burning roll of toilet paper. Trash. This was after sitting in my tupperdor for three months so there were no RH problems or anything to blame it on other than being trash. Worst cigar I've ever had and I've smoked a Boneshaker.151
January 21, 2017
Jason K.
ChurchillCan't go wrong with this beauty... Flavor draw and consistency always predictable551
January 7, 2017
CLIFF W.
ChurchillNow you know what I'm saying Where Art Thou fart now peace out my brother smoke em if you got them451
December 22, 2016
Michael H.
ChurchillFrom reading all of the other reviews I feel like the batch I just finished smoking must have been a fluke. Draw was rather tight and the burn was incredibly inconsistent. One of the worst I've had on any cigar. But when they were burning the flavor was exceptional. I don't think this will be a repeat purchase in bulk but I won't hesitate to pickup single sticks at my local shop.351
October 22, 2016
Drate B.
ChurchillThis is one of my favorite cigars of all time. Good medium flavor and great for anytime of the day.551
October 14, 2016
Kevin R.
ChurchillA slightly spicier version of the regular 1875. The first one I smoked had some draw problems but that's to be expected with even the best cigars from time to time. Overall a very good smoke and one that I'll be buying again once I have more humidor space.451
October 10, 2016
Drate B.
ChurchillGreat construction and draw everything i was looking for in a cigar. good for a relaxing afternoon and would reccomend it.451
July 9, 2016
Joey B.
ChurchillFirst time with this beautiful cigar. I like they come in 27 count boxes. These cigars are a work of art. Awesome flavors. The aroma gets my mouth watering.551
June 27, 2016
K J.
ChurchillNot a bad stick nice medium flavor great to have in humi love it I keep a lot of these for new guys451
June 21, 2016
David J.
ChurchillThis is a great cigar. I smoked it as far down as I could and it was just as smooth from the first draw to the last.551
March 6, 2016
Pete F.
ChurchillThis is a nice smoke with h a great smell both before and during the smoke. I recommend this one.551
October 22, 2015
TIM C.
ChurchillExcellent stick. Lasted over two hours so keep for a night where you have the time551
October 11, 2015
Dylan T.
ChurchillR&J cigars are one of my favorites. You will find on this cigar the construction to be consistent from box to box. My only issue is that this cigars draw from time to time is spotty. My first cigar from this box was perfect but the next two’s draw became an issue almost as if the cigar was plugged.351
September 21, 2015
DAVID W.
ChurchillOne of my favorite cigars551
July 16, 2015
BRIAN F.
ChurchillGreat buy for stocking humidor. Excellent medium smoke that won't break the bank. Slow draw that's consistent.451
July 13, 2015
MIKE B.
ChurchillThis R&J is one of my favorites. You will always find the construction draw and flavor to be consistent from box to box. A good looking cigar that lives up to the Romeo name.551
June 15, 2015
WARD M.
ChurchillFor the price this is one of the best medium bodied cigars I have had. I order about 2 boxes a month.451
June 14, 2015
PAT M.
ChurchillOne of my favorite churchills. Classic habano flavor flawless construction that usually burns evenly. The best stick from RyJ.451
April 21, 2015
DESMOND J.
ChurchillGreat Smokes551
June 25, 2019
DANIELD M.
ChurchillA great cigar551
June 25, 2019
William G.
ChurchillI bought these for my dad. He said they are very good, and he does like them. However, he still thinks the JR Ultimate (UL1) is the best. I will buy the JR Ultimate next time.451
June 29, 2019
ALFRED F.
ChurchillDisappointed351
June 29, 2019
Greg H.
ChurchillHuge amount of nuts and cream...perfect draw all the time....occasional side burn551
July 3, 2019
ROBERT E.
Churchillconsistant flavor and draw. smooth to the last bit of the cigar.551
July 22, 2019
Jack Kennedy
ChurchillGreat value in this cigar.451
September 11, 2019
RICHARD S.
ChurchillGreat smoke. A reliable cigar.551
September 11, 2019
Mike R.
ChurchillI've been smoking this cigar for years. Great draw, great flavor right down to the end.551
September 12, 2019
PAT M.
ChurchillI bought these after watching Darkest Hour and was pleasantly surprised by how good they are. Perfect with a scotch on the porch.451
September 29, 2019
Adam C.
ChurchillThis is like my third box of these that I buy to smoke on the golf course and they are great. I don’t know how to describe them but there smooth all the way through!!551
October 5, 2019
HERIBERTO R.
ChurchillI won this five pack and was blown away by the flavor and the consistency of the burn. Nice smoke flow from cigar. Looks plan but it really great cigar.551
January 23, 2019
Jason C.
ChurchillA very different kind of R&J this is a powerhouse of intense earth and leather with a deep rich sweetness that will have your head spinning. Be sure to give them lots of dry-box time and smoke them slowly for best burn and flavor. A cigar for the experienced smoker with a strong head and a full stomach.451
December 24, 2018
Michael N.
ChurchillI have smoked four of my five pack and each one has been different. The first one was so tightly wrapped I couldn't smoke but the other 3 were good. Uneven burn.351
October 26, 2018
Ronald P.
ChurchillWon these in a auction they have a good flavor An smooth Even burn .Worth every penny would bid on them again451
August 22, 2018
Randal T.
ChurchillRomeo romeo wherefore art thou romeo?
Winston Churchill would be delighted to spark one up here and now if he where still around.551
September 2, 2018
Brandon L.
ChurchillThis Romeo Churchill had a nice rich flavor. The wrapper was very rich and smooth and not harsh as I has expected.451
October 10, 2017
Matt G.
ChurchillIncredible flavor. Not a tight wrap so you get a very good draw. These have been my favorite for years.Closer to Medium body than Full.551
August 10, 2017
Pat M.
ChurchillCan't go wrong with this beauty... Flavor draw and consistency always predictable551
January 7, 2017
Cliff W.
ChurchillThese Romeo Maduros are one of my favorites. Bold earthy flavor with a bit of spice. Two of these babies will last for 18 holes.451
January 6, 2017
Clifford T.
ChurchillA really well made if slightly tight drawing in the first 10 minutes cigar that reminds you why the big dogs are the big dogs! Better than any boutique blend I've had recently.451
October 31, 2016
Jason K.
ChurchillThis is an outstanding cigar in the mild to medium range with full flavors. The smoke is creamy tobacco with cocoa staying smooth the whole way through. It is a long lasting cigar which was perfect for a sunny Saturday afternoon with a book and Glenmorangie original scotch. I love full bodied cigar but this could very well be a perfect everyday cigar in a smaller size.551
October 25, 2016
Jason N.
ChurchillThis is a great flavored smoke at an exceptional value but the construction is HORRIBLE! When you factor in how much how much fluid it takes to keep lighting this cigar I guess it's not even that great of a value. A flop from a great name in the business. Long live the anniversario.251
September 26, 2016
Greg S.
ChurchillThis cigar is a bit stronger then I was use to but I adjusted fairly quickly. JR s right with their review.451
October 22, 2015
Tim C.
ChurchillSmooth relaxing smoke. Great with a single malt scotch It is a true delight from the time you light up to the last puff.451
June 18, 2015
James B.
ChurchillI had never had a bad Romeo before.
I scooped 2 from a friend's humidor to have outside while I was running my smoker and they were Churchills. They looked great, well put together and I was looking forward to them. Took the first one out and it felt very loosely wrapped. As I lit it the draw was more like a lack of draw made it difficult to light. The start was bitter and the draw just wasn't there. I kept looking to see if there was a pin hole but could find none. When I did inhale I could hear the crackling of the tobacco. By the last third it had settled down somewhat but it never developed a proper flavor profile and the bitterness remained and the burn was very inconsistant. All in all too much work for a mediocre experience. Never having had a bad Romeo before I lit the second one a while later expecting much better ... same thing. I tossed it after a third and got smaller cigars from my own humidor. Did I get the only two bad ones they ever made? Just disappointed.251
March 8, 2020
fred g.
ChurchillPerfect inexpensive cigar for the round of golf - one for the front, one for the back.451
March 25, 2020
JOE F.
ChurchillGreat cigar. My every day go to stogie. Never lets me down551
March 29, 2020
Mike R.
ChurchillMade well, smokes well and tastes good. All for a reasonable price.451
March 29, 2020
ANDREW G.
ChurchillRomeo Habano Reserve551
March 31, 2020
DANIEL H.
ChurchillThe reserve churchil is a great smoke551
April 2, 2020
JOHN A.
ChurchillFabulous cigar With medium high octane, but not as stout as a Nicaraguan euro. Perfect draw and construction. Highly recommended.551
June 14, 2020
Matthew B.
ChurchillVery good Cigar451
January 20, 2021
JOSEPH S.
ChurchillNice tightly wrapped smoke with slow burn.551
January 20, 2021
TOM H.
ChurchillWas not expecting the madero version, but kept them to try. A little too much pepper on the back of the throat, but the rich flavor was very good; did’n’t get the dark chocolate some were talking about. Flavors were woodsy, barnyard ( in a good way), a little nut, and creamy.351
January 20, 2021
JACK G.
ChurchillSolid smoke with great flavor551
January 22, 2021
MICHAEL M.
ChurchillMy first of the R&J Churchill variety, and I'm pleased. I little milder than I expected, but good construction, good consistency, and good flavor. Work the price.551
January 30, 2021
Chuck
ChurchillVery smooth and good draw cigar.551
April 2, 2021
Robert C.
ChurchillOne of my favorite cigars.551
July 12, 2021
E. J.
ChurchillFirst 3rd was a little tight, but it opened up nicely after that. Pretty traditional R&J flavor. Enjoyed it, and worth the price, but not outstanding. Would buy again of the price was right.451
July 30, 2021
Matt S.
ChurchillThis is everything I want in a cigar. Good notes of Caramel ,earth, hay and buttery smoke. They even sneak a hint of pepper in there towards the middle which is replaced by the natural sugars to sweeten that smoking session. I love this cigar and will be ordering another 5 pack soon. Enjoy!551
September 6, 2021
J-Diego-L
ChurchillIt’s one of the best cigars I have smoked551
September 16, 2021
Ahmad D.
Churchillmy favorite551
October 30, 2021
tom
ChurchillMy husband loves Romeo Juliette Churchill reserves551
November 11, 2021
STACY G.
ChurchillCreamy, nutty, with a little wood! Puns aside...you get ALL those flavors. Construction USED to be great but lately they've been center burning.
Still pretty happy with these...ive ordered like 20 boxes!551
April 18, 2022
BigRob!
ChurchillAn outstanding cigar without breaking the bank. I bought a box on the recommendation of a buddy and they have not disappointed... a good burn, smooth draw, and amazing taste. I highly recommend!551
April 29, 2022
Marcus
Churchilln/a551
May 28, 2022
John D.
ChurchillGreat cigar551
June 6, 2022
Kenneth W.
ChurchillOverall, this is a reasonably good smoke. However, the construction is a bit too soft/spongy to my liking. But worst of all, two cigars out of my five-pack began “canoeing” immediately upon lighting, and it resulted in a much less satisfactory smoke than I normally enjoy. Canoeing is extremely difficult to “fix” if you at all can. Moreover, I have had no reply of any sort from JR Cigar relative to this problem. I ask only for two different replacement cigars, of their choosing. Therefore, would I order this cigar again? Probably not, specifically for these two reasons.251
June 12, 2022
Bo T.
ChurchillNot for me at all haha. First 3rd was a leather bomb. From there it took on an earthy woodieness with a nutty bitterness. Tasted like what I imagine acorns to taste like haha
Otherwise well constructed with a good draw.251
August 13, 2022
Josh
ChurchillDid not enjoy my first one, had to light several times, draw was terrible, second time did not enjoy a jr cigar, had one last night much better251
September 2, 2022
Leslie s.
ChurchillGood Cigar551
October 18, 2022
Tim B.
ChurchillGreat cigar real good flavor and they burn very even. real enjoy them551
December 22, 2022
Ray
Churchilllittle dried out351
March 15, 2023
DOUGLAS L.
ChurchillGreat cigar , Its quality is uniform and tastes good451
March 18, 2023
Javier M.
ChurchillEnjoyable551
April 10, 2023
Frank S.
ChurchillInconsistent, some are tightly rolled, others not so much!451
April 12, 2023
DAVID L.
ChurchillDecent cigar, good draw, burned evenly, more of a medium smoke. smooth, no bad after taste.451
April 25, 2023
Hume D.
ChurchillThis was my ‘go to’ and favorite smoke, Just received my shipment and couldn’t wait to try my first cigar. Went out half way, Seems dry in some parts. Cut another one in half to check, seems dry as well. Too bad, these used to be my favorite!351
May 20, 2023
Lakecruiser1
ChurchillGreat551
June 10, 2023
Oliver J.
ChurchillAlways try to keep a few of these "go to" sticks in the humidor. Mellow and flavorful, long burn and consistent!551
June 11, 2023
MANUEL B.
ChurchillGood cigars but they don’t burn the way I’d like them too. They go out alot451
June 28, 2023
Susan B.
ChurchillNice cigar good taste and draw551
June 30, 2023
Mikhail
ChurchillI had high hopes from this traditional brand. I found ash that just fell away all over my shirt(asbestos shirt next time)!!! An even smoke but bland flavor.....just wasn't for me.351
July 2, 2023
Daniel B.
ChurchillI had ordered R&J Riserva Real churchills, but instead got R&J Riserva Real 1875 churchills. Not sure if there's much difference...they smoke okay, but either the order-taker didn't understand what I wanted or the order got garbled when it was sent to shipping. It would have been nice to receive what I thought I had ordered. Then I found that the price had dropped considerably the next day. What's up with that?????351
July 4, 2023
RICHARD F.
ChurchillLove this cigar good smile all the way thru551
July 7, 2023
Stephen D.
ChurchillExactly what you’d expect451
July 10, 2023
ROBERT R.
ChurchillYou sent the wrong cigars did not receive what is pictured.551
July 23, 2023
Marvin h.
ChurchillAwesome cigat551
October 21, 2023
Gayle M.
ChurchillGreat cigar!!551
November 18, 2023
WilliamA H.
ChurchillNot the best. Not the worst. At least it doesn't taste bad.351
December 15, 2023
Seamus F.
ChurchillSlow smoking full of flavor with an even burn. For the money an excellent value!551
July 10, 2024
Rick
ChurchillI would give it a 5 star but afraid y'all might raise the price.451
August 5, 2024
Marvin
ChurchillThis is a great smoke. Highly recommend. Great flavor to the end.551
August 14, 2024
steve f.
ChurchillAs always a perfect cigar to relax with, never fail to deliver. Strongly suggest you try them if you haven’t.551
August 21, 2024
Reuben B.
ChurchillThis Churchill is my go to everyday smoke.451
November 21, 2024
Michael N.
ChurchillExcellent cigar. Very enjoyable smoke with a nice Bourbon or Scotch. I have been a repeat buyer of this cigar and I will continue to do so.551
December 6, 2024
ERIK K.
ChurchillThe best Cigars, I enjoy them daily.551
January 8, 2025
J
ChurchillFirst time buyer of these. They were okay. Taste fluctuates a bit too much for my taste.451
January 30, 2025
Fernando A.
Romeo y Julieta Reserve
Churchill
7 × 54
RHRCH
The Romeo y Julieta Reserve Churchill is a high-octane version of the popular Dominican brand made to please those who prefer a fuller bodied flavor. The dark and oily Nicaraguan wrapper chosen for the Reserve is a real beauty to behold. In addition, with its flawless construction, robust flavors, and the finest blend of Nicaraguan and Honduran filler leaf, Sir Winston would have been proud of this Churchill! It is conveniently sold in boxes of 27.