MAHP53
4.28125
64
Hyde Park
This is surprisingly strongly and more flavorful than other macanudos that I’ve tried. Really well done smoke. Will definitely smoke again.
4
5
1
March 24, 2018
Jonathan B.
Hyde Park
This is a good flavorful nice tasting stick with a nice aroma. I have had two of them now and they seem to have a good build also. I can't give a five star but they are a four star stick.
4
5
1
April 2, 2017
Steve B.
Hyde Park
a good tasting smoke with a nice aroma with no after taste and a good build
4
5
1
March 25, 2017
Steve B.
Hyde Park
Love the maduro. Not a whole lot of flavor but good enough to smoke daily. An everyday cigar. Mild to medium in flavor. Can't smoke the high end full flavor all the time.
4
5
1
November 10, 2016
TERESA H.
Hyde Park
Got one in a sample pack and right away I noticed that the wrapper leaf looked sloppy and the cap was lopsided making the cut difficult. Probably would be better to punch instead of cut. Aside from the construction I thought the smoke was very flavorful with a rich coffee taste. Flavors came and went throughout the smoke but there was never any hot spots or bad flavors.
3
5
1
October 28, 2016
Michael H.
Hyde Park
This one was about palatable then I smoked a Lil more and throw it away and smoke a good stick
3
5
1
July 28, 2016
David J.
Hyde Park
This is another good one that holds up to the name and does not let down at all
4
5
1
July 19, 2016
Jonathan H.
Hyde Park
Found the draw was a bit harder to draw the outer wrapper was not that great! Peeling of the wrapper was common!
3
5
1
June 19, 2016
Gregory L.
Hyde Park
Decent cigar with full
Flavor of coffee and pepper. Very decent draw and construction. Nice finish as well
4
5
1
June 13, 2016
DENNIS G.
Hyde Park
This cigar was a real treat by macanudo. Dont let the dark wrapper scare u if ur into milder smokes because this thing is medium bodied at best. Nice hints of coffee throughout
5
5
1
April 30, 2016
Jesse Z.
Hyde Park
Really great smoke. I always keep these in stock in my humidor. Dark color rich flavor very consistent.
4
5
1
February 2, 2016
Erik P.
Hyde Park
This might be the best that Macanudo has to offer. Beautiful dark oily wrapper with almost invisible seams. Great draw and razor sharp burn. Packed with flavor. I guess there's always a first time.
5
5
1
December 28, 2015
Matthew M.
Hyde Park
A very mild maduro. A mild bodied smoke with slightly more flavor than a regular Macanudo.
4
5
1
December 19, 2015
CHRISTOPHER F.
Hyde Park
The macanudos are my favorite cigar and the maduro has a awesome flavor. It's a perfect smoke for anytime. The price isn't bad either you can usually find them for around 5 bucks a stick
5
5
1
September 18, 2015
Aaron W.
Hyde Park
It has all of Macanudo’s signature smooth flavors but with the added complexity of a broadleaf wrapper. Good cigar to get acquainted with what a maduro wrapper brings to a cigar
4
5
1
February 18, 2019
Matthew D.
Hyde Park
great cigar and price
5
5
1
November 22, 2019
DAVID S.
Hyde Park
Ordered 10 cigars. Received only eight cigars
3
5
1
January 24, 2019
Paul L.
Hyde Park
A very dark rustic looking cigar. Performed well with an even burn and solid white ash. Flavors are balanced and medium bodied with a leathery and spicy taste.
4
5
1
November 13, 2018
Damon C.
Hyde Park
Another great cigar from Macanudo. I prefer a larger cigar but these are very tasty. The cigar hold up well to s firm wet bite. Subtle sweetness from the maduro wrapper. Very tasty I prefer slighter wrapper for more pepper notes.
3
5
1
January 26, 2018
Richard J.
Hyde Park
I dont usually smoke macanudo. Reminds me of miller lite of beer. But someone offered me one of these. This was very much doable. Nice smooth fermented smoke and taste. Usual maduro creaminess. I would definitely be willing to do it again.
4
5
1
October 2, 2017
Ted K.
Hyde Park
Mild to medium body. Great draw good even burn pretty flavorful for a milder cigar. A nice after dinner cugqr
5
5
1
August 21, 2017
Jason H.
Hyde Park
Quite tasty and stayed lit while riding my Harley Davidson in a parade for 2 hours
4
5
1
January 3, 2017
Peter N.
Hyde Park
This was hands down the best Macanudo I've smoked ever. It's an average cigar at best but a lot better than the others I've smoked.
3
5
1
December 23, 2016
Garron F.
Hyde Park
This cigar had a very different type of flavor. It was a extremely smooth cigar that was fruity and bold. Each stage of the cigar seemed to offer something different. Very enjoyable.
4
5
1
November 6, 2016
Troy F.
Hyde Park
A heavier smoke than the tradition Macanudo. Spicier and with more of a flavor punch. Medium body and pretty well made. Several had tight draws but we all know how to fix that. Give them a try if you want a stronger cigar with the same quality of Macanudo.
4
5
1
October 21, 2016
Jason S.
Hyde Park
This cigar was one of the monthly sampler packs. Started very harsh smoothed a bit midway through. I found the harshness distracting way over priced for the smoke. No more Macanudo's for me.
3
5
1
September 24, 2016
Duane R.
Hyde Park
I really liked it. Top notch. Give it a try for yourself. I have several more left in the humidor but kinda makes a dilema.... do I smoke them all now or make them last
5
5
1
August 12, 2016
Andy C.
Hyde Park
As with other reviewers Macanudos are my goto smokes but the quality is obviously falling off with the construction being 'hollow' and then the burn being hot. Taste is good when the smoke is consistent.
3
5
1
May 27, 2016
Tony G.
Hyde Park
The Hyde Park version of the Macanudo Maduro is not as good as the Prince Phillip. The taste is harsher. The draw less consistent. The construction slightly lower quality. It is an OK smoke for the price but my preference will remain the Prince Phillip version of this cigar brand.
3
5
1
November 5, 2015
Tony G.
Hyde Park
One of the go to cigars. It's definitely on the mild side so a nice midday smoke. Wish the price was a little better as even on sale it's the same price as the store
4
5
1
September 21, 2015
Adam K.
Hyde Park
Nice smooth smoke. A 'go to' when you're just relaxing by the pool or wherever! I give these to clients and they never disappoint.
4
5
1
June 9, 2015
Howard K.
Hyde Park
Always find the Macanudo Maduro to be a very tasty and creamy blend that I regularly keep in my humidors. The construction and draw where very consistent.
5
5
1
April 14, 2020
BOB D.
Hyde Park
Was a great smoke would recommend
4
5
1
August 5, 2020
Art O.
Hyde Park
Just a great all around cigar!
5
5
1
September 20, 2020
Smelly A.
Hyde Park
have to admit these were in my list of must try and when 10 pack on sale, I bought them. Glad I did. Flavorful and smooth. Good construction. I will keep them as a regular for sure. Try them.
4
5
1
October 17, 2020
Jf
Hyde Park
Excellent cigar for the price
4
5
1
November 29, 2020
Bandar m.
Hyde Park
I prefer a mild cigar but at the same time I like a "real" cigar. This Macondo fits the bill, with the right taste not sweet nor harsh.
5
5
1
January 20, 2021
DJ M.
Hyde Park
Perfect size,.. overall very enjoyable
5
5
1
January 20, 2021
Mark Z.
Hyde Park
Good addition to the humidor. Good flavor and draw! Great evening smoke to end the day!
4
5
1
May 10, 2021
David
Hyde Park
Nice smooth well balance smoke
4
5
1
August 25, 2021
David B.
Hyde Park
Smooth, well constructed, balanced cigar. Hints of chocolate, coffee...not to sweet. Will buy again. Goes greatat with a cold Dunkelweisen.
4
5
1
October 9, 2021
Jamie C.
Hyde Park
Awesome cigar from a true Maduro smoker, well constructed, smooth smoke, just can’t say enough about this cigar, other than awesome
5
5
1
June 2, 2022
Elbowdie
Hyde Park
Smooth, aromatic and easy on the draw
5
5
1
June 8, 2022
James M.
Hyde Park
Well worth the price.
5
5
1
June 14, 2022
RANDY S.
Hyde Park
Love this cigar. Always consistent in every way. Great medium flavor strength. Not too spicy or bitter. One of my favs
5
5
1
June 17, 2022
Eli
Hyde Park
Nice stick mellow and just the rite draw I like. I bought these in a five pack just to give them a try. I'll be picking up a box in the near future.
4
5
1
July 18, 2022
Scott
Hyde Park
This is one of my favorite sticks. Great flavor and even burn. Definitely my go to smoke. Just picked up another box. Give them a try you won't be disappointed.
5
5
1
July 24, 2022
Scott
Hyde Park
one of best maduros out there
5
5
1
October 15, 2022
craig h.
Hyde Park
Goes great with my morning coffee very smooth
4
5
1
October 22, 2022
Damon H.
Hyde Park
The first third of this cigar seems unremarkable, almost harsh, but the second third mellows nicely, and the flavors start to develop. The last third IMO is when this cigar shines. Nice chocolate flavor balanced with spicy pepper and no bitterness right down to the nub. I will let some of these have some more time in the humidor and I expect more enjoyable smokes from these nice cigars.
4
5
1
October 31, 2022
Steve R.
Hyde Park
A total pleasure from beginning to end. The cold taste is enjoyable with notes of cocoa, cherry and mild spice. The draw is excellent as is the consistency, construction, aroma, and flavor. Notes of cocoa, mild cherry, some coffee, and leather. Overall, it is a masterpiece. And the price is very reasonable for a cigar of this quality. Interestingly, although it is a true maduro, it is medium in strength.
5
5
1
December 15, 2022
Kenny S.
Hyde Park
One of my favorites. Tasty, great draw, great construction.
5
5
1
December 30, 2022
William77
Hyde Park
What I learned was premium as a young man. Musty maduro that always sweats, gives great flavor notes and stays smooth to the nub
5
5
1
February 19, 2023
MaduroJoe
Hyde Park
Always enjoy these puppies! Just a good smoke!!
4
5
1
February 23, 2023
Ron B.
Hyde Park
Great tasting cigar,smoothe,will buy again
5
5
1
March 9, 2023
Tommy R.
Hyde Park
These have been my favorite cigar for twenty years. I highly recommend them to anyone who is looking for a mellow smoke.
5
5
1
April 8, 2023
joseph l.
Hyde Park
A great cigar. Very flavorful at a good price
5
5
1
April 12, 2023
FERDINAND O.
Hyde Park
Fantastic flavor
5
5
1
July 21, 2023
Duane P.
Hyde Park
These cigars are a gift for my son!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
5
5
1
July 30, 2023
Thomas K.
Hyde Park
I thoroughly enjoyed this cigar. Great burn and consistency. Sweet flavors of spice and earthy goodness. Will buy again.
4
5
1
November 5, 2023
Joe H.
Hyde Park
Bought these on a great deal. Excellent construction and flavor. Absolutely would purchase again when price is right...
5
5
1
December 2, 2023
Joe V.
Hyde Park
I would rate this an excellent cigar if it had not gotten awful strong/rank the last little bit. Up until that point it was an excellent cigar.
4
5
1
February 2, 2024
JIM B.
Hyde Park
I got one of these in a cigar grab bag, ten for thirty bucks. I've never been a huge fan of Macanudo, they are too mild for my tastes. This maduro was a gem, beautiful construction, shiny and oily. The wrapper tasted very good. I was pleasantly surprised and thoroughly enjoyed it for about an hour. Beautiful, firm white ash with dead even burn. The smoke had great though mild flavor, the retro-hale was satisfying. I'm not sure I would pay full price for another one because I'd be more apt to go for something on the bold side of medium. But this cigar was definitely good. I'd recommend it to someone who is still developing their palate.
5
5
1
June 25, 2024
Mark
Hyde Park
For the most part these are excellent cigars. I have had several boxes and I don't share! The only problem I have had with them was one box of 25 was inconsistent. Several of the sticks had very dry wrappers and some were packed so tight an elephant couldn't have smoked them. However, overall I like them and will order more as soon as I finish off my current order.
5
5
1
September 12, 2024
NHMike
Macanudo Maduro
Hyde Park
5.50 × 49
MAHP53
Pick up a 5-pack of Macanudo Maduro Hyde Park cigars right here at JR, and you will quickly realize why it is one of the most popular Dominican brands in the world. The richness of an oily licorice black Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper paired with perfectly aged tobaccos from the Dominican Republic and Mexico, reward the cigar aficionado with sweet-smelling medium body flavors of chocolate, sweet spice, leather, cedar, and coffee. The premium handmade Macanudo Maduro Hyde Park is undoubtedly one of the most satisfying maduro cigars available today.
Read more